Fear of dissent. I’ve made the assertion before based on personal observation, but more evidence is rolling in. Not only are we apparently becoming more polarized as a nation, but more and more we’re consciously blocking out any news, information, or opinion that doesn’t jive with our own.
The New York Times recently ran a story speculating about the future fate of CNN, “a network whose strategy is to steer the middle course in its news coverage,” in light of viewers jumping ship for more the more biased Fox News and MSNBC.
It would seem that no one wants just plain news anymore; everyone wants talking heads spouting opinions that never waver from the ideological comfort blankets we carry with us. Hearing the other side makes us uncomfortable — or worse, offended.
[I'm fully prepared for Fox News fans to blast me and the NYT for suggesting that CNN is in the middle, but CNN's news-to-bloviating ratio is infinitely higher than that of their rivals. And while they used to be known as the Clinton News Network for their unabashed support of the former president, objective observers now can not deny they are closer to the middle than ever, and much more centered than FNC or MSNBC.]
I even lost an old friend because of this phenomenon. An old high school classmate of mine was spouting Fox News talking points on Facebook on a regular basis. He eventually “dumped” me as a friend for challenging his opinions. The arguments never got personal (at least I didn’t think of them as such because while I have strong political opinions I don’t define myself by them), but apparently he’d rather stick with his own “kind.” After all, when your world is black and white I guess grays are a nuisance.
It’s sad. Sad that we may soon see the end of (relatively) unbiased news. Sad that we can no longer stomach disagreement. And sad that we wrap ourselves so tightly in our own beliefs that we live in echo chambers with nothing but electronic versions of Yes Men coddling us everywhere we turn.
[I feel obligated to point out two bright exceptions to this trend: fellow WV bloggers Muze Euterpe and Elvis Drinkmo. Muze and I have gone many rounds in the political argument ring on our blogs and have always maintained mutual respect and friendship. Elvis hit me pretty hard in a political discussion on someone else's blog recently but shortly thereafter apologized in case I took offense -- which I didn't.]
—
Now what? Because of our growing inability as a society to disagree civilly, I’m close to giving up political debating entirely. What was once a career turned into a hobby, but though I maintain strong political beliefs — some conservative, some liberal — I’m past the point of wanting to argue for them anymore. It accomplishes nothing.
It hit me the other day when someone online made an outrageous statement equating Obama’s fans to Rush Limbaugh’s. How do you reason with someone like that? Would any amount of rational argument force them to second-guess their stance? What purpose does it serve to try? You’d be better off trying to convince me that Hannah Montana is a better musician than Jimmy Page.
Of course I’ll still tilt at windmills occasionally here and on the podcast, but I think my days of arguing about it all are over. It’s just not worth it.
—
Look! Up in the sky! I’m really enjoying the brouhaha caused by the recent Air Force One photo shoot over the skies of Manhattan. Now we’re seeing news reports on everything from who in the White House knew what and when to how much we taxpayers paid for the fiasco.
Lost in all of this is one simple fact:
PEOPLE WERE FRIGHTENED BY AN AIRPLANE.
I wonder if it’s too early to look for an Air Force One costume for Trick or Treat this year.
DING DONG.
“Well hello. Happy Hallowe–Oh my God. RUN!!!”
—
New Toy. I’ve been having oodles of fun with my new Nintendo DSi(tm). It’s a nice step up from the DS Lite. I may write a more in-depth review of it later (because I’m sure there just aren’t enough of them on the internet already), but so far I love it. My only complaint is that the battery life is significantly less than the DS Lite, so keep the charger close by.
Games I’ve been playing:
Pokemon Platinum
Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars
Chrono Trigger
—
I wonder if The Queen would give me her old one? My venerable third generation iPod(tm) finally bit the dust recently. Everything works but the click wheel, so I just can’t scroll through my song lists to select what I want to hear. So now it has become a glorified external hard drive for my music collection.
I’m considering a new one because both my car stereo and home theater receiver have iPod connectors, but I’m not yet sure I want to pay the Apple tax again when a much less expensive player would do the trick. We’ll see.
For the time being I’m surviving with my iPod connected to my computer at work, and a cheapie Insignia Sport(tm) 2GB player for listening to podcasts in the car.